-Written by Michelle Vorob.
2024 CAMDEN INTERNATIONAL FILM FESTIVAL REVIEW!
Meditations on Silence is a creative documentary by Sebastián Quiroz, addressing the Chilean Social Revolt of 2019. The revolt was comprised of a series of mass demonstrations and extreme riots, in response to societal issues.
We are informed by an on-screen message the documentary is composed of film fragments produced in Chile between 1910 and 2022, including some from propaganda films made under Pinochet's dictatorship, between 1974 and 1975.
Meditations on Silence includes information about someone known as “X”, who, during the revolt, was taken and held by the police. While being held, “X” could hear screaming, sounds of someone being tortured, but police insisted this was not the case. Meditations on Silence also includes information regarding people injured by police during the demonstrations and riots, but that only a miniscule amount of people have received justice, while the statute of limitations is about to expire for most of these cases.
Despite simply relaying some information, Meditations on Silence takes on a cinematic feel. It could be likened to a political thriller, or even a story about espionage. Quiroz was not afraid to be bold in telling some truths about what happened during the revolt, in an effort to spread awareness about some of the injustices and abuse suffered by the public [while they were ironically protesting injustices].
Peaceful protests can and do bring about meaningful social change, however, I do not abide by rioting as a means to express that sentiment. Mob mentality is almost hypnotic and extremely dangerous. People injure each other, kill each other, destroy neighbors’ homes and businesses. While I am appalled by the manner in which people were injured by police, I don't see that could be completely avoided in such a situation. On the other hand, anyone injured by police in any way should have their case heard and if they are due compensation for it, they should rightly have it.
Meditations on Silence, while dealing specifically with the Chilean Social Revolt [of 2019], is also an interesting and relevant thought exercise on ethics, social change, and social dynamics with global applications. While I personally would have also appreciated a straightforward, educational documentary about these events, I was impressed by the cinematic style and tone of this creative, short documentary.
Quiroz was effective with his message and bringing light to those who are still in need of justice. Meditations on Silence is currently available to watch online, during the virtual half of the 20th annual Camden International Film Festival [CIFF]. There are many wonderful documentaries available online, now through September 30th.
Written and Directed by Sebastián Quiroz.
8/10 = WORTH RENTING OR BUYING
Comments